Are you an English learner struggling with modal verbs? Words like “should,” “could,” and “would” can feel tricky, especially when talking about “what if” moments in life. These modals help us dream about possibilities, give advice, or express regrets. But what’s the should, could, would difference in hypothetical situations? Don’t worry, this guide breaks it down simply.
In this post, we’ll explore advanced modal verbs like never before. You’ll learn about perfect modals explained in easy steps, dive into unreal conditional scenarios, and master expressing regret with should have. By the end, you’ll confidently use these verbs in everyday chats. Let’s make English fun and clear!
Whether you’re a beginner or brushing up your skills, this article is your roadmap. Stick around for tips, examples, and a quick quiz to test your knowledge.
Understanding Modal Verbs
Modal verbs are like secret tools in English. They add flavor to sentences without changing the main action. Think of them as helpers that show possibility, advice, or imagination.
Common modals include “can,” “may,” “must,” and our stars today are should, could, and would.
Modals don’t need “to” after them. Say “I should go” not “I should to go.” Simple, right?
But in hypothetical situations, those “if only” dreams, these modals shine. Hypothetical means “not real, just imagining.” Like, “If I won the lottery, what would I do?” Understanding the difference helps you sound natural, not robotic.
Why learn this now? English tests like TOEFL love hypotheticals. Plus, in real life, friends share regrets or plans using these. Mastering them boosts your confidence. Ready? Let’s unpack each modal.
Before diving into should, could, and would, let’s quickly recap what a modal verb is.
A modal verb is a special type of auxiliary (or helping) verb that is always used with a main verb. Modals don’t show action; instead, they express:
- Ability (e.g., can)
- Permission (e.g., may)
- Necessity (e.g., must)
- Possibility (e.g., might)
- Advice (e.g., should)
The best part? Modal verbs are easy to use! They never change form (you never add -s, -ed, or -ing to them), and they are always followed by the base form of the main verb (the infinitive without “to”).
Example:
✔️ I would go. (Correct)
❌ She could to go. (Incorrect)
❌ He should goes. (Incorrect)
The Big Three: Should, Could, and Would
Let’s look at the specific core meanings of these three modal verbs. Think of each one as having a unique personality:
1. Should (The Advice Giver)
Should is all about giving or asking for advice, expressing an opinion about what is correct, or indicating a soft obligation (something that is a good idea to do).
| Use | Meaning | Beginner-Friendly Example |
| Advice/Recommendation | It is a good idea to do this. | You should study every day to improve. |
| Expectation | This is likely to happen. | The movie should be exciting. |
| Soft Obligation | It is your duty or responsibility. | I should call my mother tonight. |
Key Takeaway: When you use should, you are talking about what is right or best to do.
2. Could (The Possibility Pointer)
Could has two main jobs:
- It is the past tense of can (to express past ability).
- It expresses a possibility or a future option (present/future ability).
| Use | Meaning | Beginner-Friendly Example |
| Past Ability | I was able to do this in the past. | When I was young, I could run very fast. |
| Possibility/Option | This is a possible action or choice. | We could go to the park or the beach tomorrow. |
| Polite Request | Asking nicely for something. | Could you please help me with my homework? |
Key Takeaway: When you use could, you are talking about what is possible or what ability you (or someone else) have.
3. Would (The Dreamer)
Would is the key modal verb for describing things that are not real. It is the ultimate hypothetical word! It shows you are speaking about an imagined action or situation, often dependent on a condition (the “if” part of a sentence).
| Use | Meaning | Beginner-Friendly Example |
| Conditional/Hypothetical | The result of an unreal condition. | If I won the lottery, I would travel the world. |
| Past Repetition/Habit | Something done many times in the past (less common). | My grandfather would always tell me stories. |
| Polite Request/Offer | Making a request or offer very politely. | Would you like some coffee? |
Key Takeaway: When you use would, you are talking about a dream, an idea, or an imagined result.
Should, Could, Would Difference in Hypothetical Situations
Hypotheticals are sentences about unreal things. Like, “If pigs flew…” We use them for wishes, regrets, or advice on “what might have been.”
Enter unreal conditional scenarios. These are “if” sentences in three types:
- Present/Future Unreal: For imaginary now or soon.
- Past Unreal: For regrets about yesterday.
- Mixed: Blending times.
Now we put them together! This is where the magic happens and where many learners get confused. Let’s look at how their meanings change when placed into the same hypothetical situation.
Imagine a friend is complaining about being broke, and you are trying to give them advice about finding a new job.
| Modal Verb | Meaning | Example | Focus |
| Should | What is the best choice (advice/obligation). | If you are broke, you should look for a new job. | Advice/Duty |
| Could | What is a possible choice (ability/option). | If you had a better resume, you could get an interview. | Possibility/Ability |
| Would | What will happen (result) in an imagined reality. | If you found a job, you would be much happier. | Imagined Result |
You can see that even in the same context, each verb gives the sentence a completely different meaning:
- Should: Focuses on what is recommended.
- Could: Focuses on what is possible.
- Would: Focuses on what is the imagined outcome.
Present/Future Hypotheticals: Imagining Today
Picture this: You’re chatting about dreams. What modal fits?
| Would for choices: | “If I were rich, I would buy a house.” (This is what I’d pick. A personal will.) |
| Could for options: | “If I were rich, I could buy a house.” (Possible, but not sure that I’d do it.) |
| Should for advice: | “If you were rich, you should buy a house.” (Wise idea for you.) |
Spot the should could would difference? “Would” is “I choose.” “Could” is “It’s doable.” “Should” is “Do this, it’s smart.”
Example Dialogue:
Friend: “If I had wings, what would you do?”
You: “I would fly to Paris! What could you reach first?”
Friend: “I should visit family. They miss me.”Practice Tip: Swap modals in sentences. Change “would” to “could” and see the shift from “plan” to “chance.”
Past Hypotheticals: Lessons from Yesterday
For old “oops” moments, we use perfect modals explained next. But first, basics.
| In past unreal: | “If I had studied, I would have passed.” (Imagined result.) |
- Would have: Likely outcome if things changed.
- Could have: Possible, but didn’t happen.
- Should have: Regret or missed duty.
The difference? “Would have” feels fated. “Could have” is opportunity lost. “Should have” stings with “I knew better.”
Real-Life Scenario: Job interview flop.
“If I had prepared, I would have got the job.” (Best path.)
“I could have practiced more.” (It was open to me.)
“I should have reviewed notes.” (My fault. I slacked.)
This nails unreal conditional scenarios. Use them in stories: “If dinosaurs had not died, we could ride them today!”
The Perfect Modals Explained: Should Have, Could Have, Would Have
If you truly want to sound like an advanced modal verbs user, you need to master the Perfect Modals. This is where we talk about the past, specifically, things that didn’t happen or things we regret. This concept moves us deeper into unreal conditional scenarios because we are talking about a past that is impossible to change.
The perfect modals explained structure is simple:
Structure: Modal Verb (should/could/would) + have + Past Participle (Verb 3).
1. Should Have (Expressing Regret with Should Have)
The most common and most important perfect modal for learners is should have. This structure is used to talk about an action in the past that you regret or an action that didn’t happen but should have.
| Use | Meaning | Beginner-Friendly Example |
| Past Regret | It was a mistake not to do this. | I should have studied harder for the exam. (I didn’t study hard, and now I regret it.) |
| Past Obligation Missed | You had a duty to do this, but you didn’t. | She should have called to tell us she was late. (She failed to meet her responsibility.) |
This is the perfect way of expressing regret with should have. It is one of the most powerful and natural-sounding phrases in English for self-correction and reflection.
2. Could Have (Unused Past Possibility)
Could have is used to talk about an action that was possible in the past but was not done. You had the option or the ability, but you chose not to use it.
Meaning: An opportunity existed, but it was missed or ignored.
| Use | Meaning | Beginner-Friendly Example |
| Unused Ability/Option | I had the ability, but I didn’t use it. | We could have driven to the concert, but we took the train instead. (Driving was an option.) |
| Past Possibility | Something was possible, but the result is uncertain. | He could have gotten the job, but he didn’t prepare well. (It was possible, but he failed.) |
3. Would Have (The Unreal Past Result)
Would have is the primary modal used in the Third Conditional to describe the unreal past result. It expresses what the result would have been if the past condition had been different.
Meaning: The imagined outcome of an impossible past action.
| Use | Meaning | Beginner-Friendly Example |
| Unreal Past Result | What would have happened if the past were different. | If I had left earlier, I would have caught the bus. (I didn’t leave early, so I didn’t catch the bus.) |
The Ultimate Unreal Conditional Scenarios
When you combine would have, could have, and should have with the Third Conditional, you are truly using advanced modal verbs to discuss the past. This structure is the most complex of the conditionals, but it allows for the deepest expression of unreal conditional scenarios.
We use the Third Conditional to talk about a hypothetical past situation that did not happen and the hypothetical result that also did not happen.
Structure: If + Subject + Had + Past Participle (Condition), Subject + Would/Could/Should Have + Past Participle (Result).
Let’s see the should could would difference in hypothetical situations when applied to the Third Conditional:
| Modal Verb | Third Conditional Example Sentence | What Does It Mean? |
| Would Have | If she had trained, she would have won the race. | This is the imagined, certain result. (She didn’t train, and she didn’t win.) |
| Could Have | If she had trained, she could have won the race. | This is the imagined, possible result (She would have had the ability/opportunity). |
| Should Have | If she had trained, she should have been happier. | This is the imagined, correct outcome (The expected result or the result that was deserved). |
This structure is a game-changer because it allows you to explain why things happened or didn’t happen, moving beyond simple facts into deep, nuanced reasoning.
Practical Tips for English Learners
To help you seamlessly integrate these advanced modal verbs into your daily speech, keep these tips in mind:
1. Focus on the Feeling
- When you use Should, you feel a sense of duty or a strong opinion.
- When you use Could, you feel a sense of possibility or option.
- When you use Would, you are imagining a different reality.
2. Practice Shortened Forms
In spoken English, the perfect modals are often contracted. Practicing these contractions will make you sound much more natural.
- Should have → Should’ve (Sounds like: “should-uv”)
Example: I should’ve called you back. - Could have → Could’ve (Sounds like: “could-uv”)
Example: We could’ve arrived earlier. - Would have → Would’ve (Sounds like: “would-uv”)
Example: She would’ve helped you.
3. Use ‘Should’ for Soft Obligations
Remember that ‘should’ is much softer than ‘must’ or ‘have to’. If you tell someone, “You should be more careful,” it’s friendly advice. If you say, “You must be more careful,” it sounds like an order. Stick with should for friendly advice!
4. Review Unreal Conditional Scenarios Often
Conditional sentences are the backbone of using these modals. Use flashcards to drill the structures:
- Second Conditional (Present/Future Unreal): If I were rich, I would…
- Third Conditional (Past Unreal): If I had known, I would have…
Practice Time: Quiz on Should, Could, Would Difference
Test yourself! Fill in: (Answers below.)
- If I (be) a bird, I would fly free.
- You should have told me earlier, we could fix it.
- In unreal scenarios, she would have danced if invited.
Answers:
1. were
2. (Correct! It fits!)
3. (Correct! Fits too!)
Score 3/3? You’re a modal pro! Miss one? Reread sections.
Master Hypotheticals Today
Congratulations! You’ve just completed a deep dive into the should could would difference in hypothetical situations. By understanding the specific roles of these three advanced modal verbs, you have gained the tools to express everything from simple advice to complex unreal conditional scenarios and deep expressing regret with should have.
The journey to English fluency is a marathon, not a sprint. Take these lessons, practice them in speaking and writing, and you will notice a huge difference in your ability to communicate complex ideas. Start small. Try to use one perfect modal today! Remember, the only way to master these verbs is to use them.
Ready to speak English that sounds thoughtful and precise? Our courses at EnglishFact demystify modal verbs! Learn how to correctly use Should, Could, and Would to express advice, possibility, and wishes. Stop guessing and level up your English with grammatical confidence.
Got questions about mastering modal verbs? Message us on WhatsApp or register for a FREE TRIAL ONLINE CLASS today!
